Heat Pump or Furnace: Which is Best for Cincinnati Homes?

Schedule Now

Homeowners often ask which is better—a heat pump or a furnace? Whether planning a new home build or needing to replace your heating or cooling system, it’s best to weigh your options.

So, what is the difference between a furnace and a heat pump? If you are unfamiliar, heat pumps offer the dual function of both heating and cooling. A heat pump moves heat around from indoors to outdoors. It can gather heat from the air outside and bring it inside during the winter. In the summer, it can gather heat from inside the house and put it outside.

A furnace, however, only performs heating. For instance, a gas furnace uses combustion to create heat and warm the house. Since a furnace only heats, your home will require additional equipment to properly cool it in the form of air conditioning.

For this reason, it’s best to weigh the pros and cons of heat pumps vs. furnaces.

Heat Pump Pros and Cons

Heat pumps have a lot to offer residents of Ohio, Kentucky, and Indiana. If you are considering replacing your heating or cooling system, replacing both with a heat pump may be best.

Consider the following advantages of having a heat pump:

  • Low Operating Costs: Perhaps the number one reason to invest in a heat pump is their significantly lower operating costs over time compared to traditional heating systems. Heat Pumps can reduce the electricity used by your heating system by up to 50 percent, according to Energy.gov. You can visit Energy Star’s Savings Calculator to see how much you can save.
  • Dual System: While a heat pump will cost more than a standard furnace or AC individually, it is usually cheaper than buying both together. Your heat pump gives you year-round comfort, giving your home an all-in-one system to rely on rather than two separate entities.
  • Eco-Friendly and Safe: Because heat pumps do not use combustion, you don’t have to worry about carbon monoxide poisoning or adding pollutants to the atmosphere.
  • More Even Temperatures: Heat pumps do not produce heated air as intensely as furnaces. The outputted air is warm but not as warm as a furnace. This means the heat pump runs longer and gradually warms up the house. The longer run times also move air through the house, pushing more air through your HVAC filter and helping remove dust.
  • Tax Credits and Rebates: You can get tax rebates and credits from the federal government and sometimes local governments for both heat pumps and furnaces. You are more likely to qualify with a heat pump, however.

On the other hand, you’ll also want to consider the disadvantages of heat pumps, as they may not be for everyone. These can include the following:

  • Higher Installation Costs: Heat pumps are more complex and expensive to purchase and install. However, they are often less costly than purchasing and installing an AC and a heater together.
  • Reduced Efficiency in Extreme Cold: The colder it is, the less efficient the unit becomes. If temperatures drop below what the heat pump can efficiently transfer, it has a less efficient electric heating element that will kick in instead.
  • Defrost: Sub-freezing temperatures can cause frost to form on outdoor heat pumps. The defrost mode must activate and melt the ice before operations can continue. Defrost mode pauses the flow of heat and increases operating costs.
  • Drafts: Because heat pumps run for longer cycles, air is constantly circulating through the house, which can begin to feel a little drafty if it’s too far from a warm air vent.
  • More Noise: Longer running cycles mean the compressor and fans run longer, creating noise for longer periods than a furnace would.
  • Lifespan: Heat pumps have a lifespan similar to an air conditioner’s—about 10 to 15 years. A gas furnace, on the other hand, can typically last 15 to 20 years.

In general, heat pumps are more energy efficient and cost less to operate than standard furnaces. They don’t risk carbon monoxide poisoning and function as both a heater and cooler. However, they are more costly to install, require more maintenance, and may struggle in extreme cold situations.

Advantages of a Furnace Over a Heat Pump

A home high efficiency furnace. Furnace Dual Stage Electronically Commutated Motors. Motor UpflowHorizontal Furnace Multi-Speed Two-Stage Energy efficient a humidefier and a water heater.

Furnaces have a few advantages over heat pumps. They heat rooms faster, with warmer air blowing through the vents. This creates larger heat differentials, which some prefer and some dislike. Furnaces have a service life of 15 to 20 years if properly maintained.

A furnace is an indoor unit, unlike a heat pump. This eliminates the risks of debris or pest infestations that an outdoor unit may be prone to.

The drawback to furnaces is that they introduce the risk of carbon monoxide poisoning. Regular furnace maintenance inspections, filter changes, and a carbon monoxide detector can mitigate these risks.

Professional Heat Pump & Furnace Installations

Apollo Home’s expert NATE-certified HVAC technicians have the training and experience to expertly install both heat pumps and furnaces in Greater Cincinnati, Northern Kentucky, and Dayton, Ohio. Our experts will work with you to determine which system will work best for your needs.

We also offer repairs and maintenance for both heat pumps and furnaces. We’ll ensure that your systems run efficiently and safely for years to come. Schedule an appointment today for a quote on a heat pump or furnace installation in Ohio or Northern Kentucky.

Flexible financing options are also available to help with installation costs. Contact us today at 513-540-3696 to learn more.

"Ernie & Mike did a superb job on my new furnace and A/C installation. Despite having more than a day’s work to do, they came in and stayed until the job was done. They were organized, efficient, and protected the rest of the house well. Got both furnace and A/C installed the same day. Ernie was courteous, informative, and clearly knew his job better than anyone I’ve encountered before. The units look so good guests now get The Tour of our new system. Apollo is clearly not a fly-by-night company. I would recommend them to anyone in need of a new furnace and/or A/C."
- Jerry A.
"I called Apollo because of a water leak I thought I had in our upstairs shower going into the kitchen. Robbie came and assured me everything was fine & looked at all the other plumbing. He ended up changing a few pipes for our washer & clearing a drain. He was very nice & knowledgeable with all my questions. I ended up signing up for the care plan & was very happy with my service."
- Cassandra B.
"The team at Apollo exceeded my expectations. As a business owner, my attention to the details and commitment to providing excellent service is high. From the sales rep. to the installation team, everyone’s performance was outstanding. For example, the installation team went to great lengths to protect our floors, placing floor runners and across the wood floors and up the stairs. They even were spot washing walls upon their departure. I highly recommend this company."
- Randy B.
"We scheduled an estimate AND a tune-up. We knew something was wrong with our furnace, but hoped we could make it through the rest of the season. Upon telling Bill what our furnace was doing, he warned us immediately what the possible outcome was going to be; a cracked heat exchanger. He watched the flames roll backward, tested carbon monoxide levels, which were so high they meter’s last reading was 5,600 before saying “high”. He immediately shut it down, tagged it, and explained that with levels that high and children in our home he wanted off right away. He continued his inspection and showed us via a camera that not only was it cracked in multiple places, but had holes all over it. He gave us a few options for repairing it; his knowledge as well as genuine concern was beneficial and refreshing. Luckily we also scheduled an estimator, Micah, to come too and we were able to get costs between repairing and replacing (with several options). We decided to replace with a much higher efficiency furnace and one sized properly to our home. Hands down, not only did they both provide us great service and knowledge, but without sounding dramatic, they may have saved our lives. This was our first time calling Apollo, but it won’t be our last."
- Sarah B.
"Apollo is an excellent company. I always receive great service. Alex A. was professional and friendly. He kept me informed during the process of checking my furnace and heat pump to make sure they were working properly. The company makes sure you are notified who is coming and when they are on the way. All my interactions with the company have been wonderful."
- Beverly S.



    Apollo Care Plan